Classification of renal masses

2016 WHO Classification of renal neoplasms[1]

(abbreviated)

  • Renal cell tumours (16)
    • Clear cell renal cell carcinoma
    • Multilocular cystic renal neoplasm of low malignant potential
    • Papillary renal cell carcinoma
    • Hereditary leiomyomatosis and renal cell carcinoma associated renal cell carcinoma
    • Chromophobe renal cell carcinoma
    • Collecting duct carcinoma
    • Renal medullary carcinoma
    • MiT family translocation renal cell carcinomas
    • Succinate dehydrogenase deficient renal cell carcinoma
    • Mucinous tubular and spindle cell carcinoma
    • Tubulocystic renal cell carcinoma
    • Acquired cystic disease associated renal cell carcinoma
    • Clear cell papillary renal cell carcinoma
    • Renal cell carcinoma, unclassified
    • Papillary adenoma
    • Oncocytoma
  • Metanephric tumors
    • Metanephric adenoma
    • Metanephric adenofibroma
    • Metanephric stromal tumor
  • Nephroblastic and cystic tumors occurring mainly in children
    • Nephrogenic rests
    • Nephroblastoma
    • Cystic partially differentiated nephroblastoma
    • Pediatric cystic nephroma
  • Mesenchymal tumors occurring mainly in children
    • Clear cell sarcoma
    • Rhabdoid tumor
    • Congenital mesoblastic nephroma
    • Ossifying renal tumor of infancy
  • Mesenchymal tumors occurring mainly in adults
    • Leiomyosarcoma (including renal vein leiomyosarcoma)
    • Angiosarcoma
    • Rhabdomyosarcoma
    • Osteosarcoma
    • Synovial sarcoma
    • Ewing sarcoma
    • Angiomyolipoma
    • Epithelioid angiomyolipoma
    • Leiomyoma
    • Hemangioma
    • Lymphangioma
    • Hemangioblastoma
    • Juxtaglomerular cell tumor
    • Renomedullary interstitial cell tumor
    • Schwannoma
    • Solitary fibrous tumor
    • Mixed epithelial and stromal tumor family
    • Adult cystic nephroma
    • Mixed epithelial and stromal tumor
  • Neuroendocrine tumors
    • Well differentiated neuroendocrine tumor
    • Large cell neuroendocrine carcinoma
    • Small cell neuroendocrine carcinoma
    • Paraganglioma
  • Miscellaneous tumors
    • Renal hematopoietic neoplasms
    • Germ cell tumors
  • Metastatic tumors
  • Tumor-like lesions
    • Xanthogranulomatous pyelonephritis
    • IgG4 related disease

There are additional described entities not currently in WHO

Classification by malignant vs. benign vs. inflammatory

  • Malignant
    • Renal cell carcinoma (RCC)
      1. Clear cell RCC
      2. Multilocular cystic renal neoplasm of low malignant potential
      3. Papillary RCC
      4. Hereditary leiomyomatosis RCC
      5. Chromophobe RCC
      6. Collecting duct carcinoma
      7. Renal medullary carcinoma
      8. MiT Family translocation carcinomas
      9. Succinate dehydrogenase (SDH) deficient RCC
      10. Mucinous tubular and spindle cell carcinoma
      11. Tubulocystic RCC
      12. Acquired cystic disease associated RCC
      13. Clear cell papillary RCC
      14. RCC, unclassified
    • Urothelium-based cancers
      • Urothelial carcinoma
      • Squamous cell carcinoma
      • Adenocarcinoma
    • Sarcomas
      • Leiomyosarcoma
      • Liposarcoma
      • Angiosarcoma
      • Hemangiopericytoma
      • Malignant fibrous histiocytoma
      • Synovial sarcoma
      • Osteogenic sarcoma
      • Clear cell sarcoma
      • Rhabdomyosarcoma
    • Wilms tumor
    • Primitive neuroectodermal tumor
    • Carcinoid tumor
    • Lymphoma/leukemia
    • Metastasis
    • Invasion by adjacent neoplasm
  • Benign
    • Cystic lesions
      • Simple cyst
      • Hemorrhagic cyst
    • Solid lesions
      • Angiomyolipoma
      • Oncocytoma
      • Renal adenoma
      • Metanephric adenoma
      • Cystic nephroma
      • Mixed epithelial-stromal tumor
      • Reninoma (juxtaglomerular cell tumor)
      • Leiomyoma
      • Fibroma
      • Hemangioma
    • Vascular lesions
      • Renal artery aneurysm
      • Arteriovenous malformation
    • Pseudotumor
  • Inflammatory
    • Abscess
    • Focal pyelonephritis
    • Xanthogranulomatous pyelonephritis
    • Infected renal cyst
    • Tuberculosis
    • Rheumatic granuloma

Renal cell carcinoma (RCC)

  • Most common (>90%) non-metastatic malignant histology of kidney tumours
    • Most common benign tumours of the kidney include oncocytoma and angiomyolipoma (AML).
  • Most common renal tumour in pregnancy[2]
  • All RCCs are adenocarcinomas
    • Most are derived from renal tubular epithelial cells of the proximal convoluted tubule
      • Exceptions include chromophobe, collecting duct, and medullary RCC (see below)

Subtypes

Histology Characteristics Familial form and genetic factors
Clear cell RCC (ccRCC)

(70-80%, most common)

Originates from proximal tubule

Prognosis generally worse compared to papillary or chromophobe

Responds to systemic therapy

von Hippel-Lindau disease

Chromosome 3p deletions (VHL inactivation by mutation or promoter hypermethylation occurs in 70-90% of clear cell renal tumors)

Multilocular cystic

ccRCC

(uncommon)

Almost uniformly benign clinical behavior Identical to ccRCC
Papillary RCC

(10-15%, 2nd most common)

Originates from proximal tubule

Commonly multifocal

Common in ESRD and acquired renal cystic disease

Type 1: good prognosis

Type 2: worse prognosis

Grade may be of greater prognostic significance than type 1 vs. 2

Current systemic therapies are ineffective against papillary RCC

Papillary adenomas are small (≤5mm) tumours that resemble papillary RCC under the microscope, are often well encapsulated and low grade, commonly found at autopsy, possess many of the same genetic alterations found in larger papillary RCCs, but are benign neoplasms

Type 1: Hereditary papillary RCC (HPRCC) syndrome

Type 2: Hereditary leiomyomatosis and RCC syndrome (HLRCC)

Trisomy of chromosomes 7 and 17 and loss of the Y chromosome.

Chromophobe RCC

(3-5%)

Originates from intercalated cells of distal tubule/collecting duct

Stains positive for Hale colloidal iron

Generally good prognosis, compared to clear cell and papillary

  • Rates of disease-specific (recurrence, metastasis, or death due disease) events following nephrectomy:[3]
    • 5 years: 3.7%
    • 10 years: 6.4%
  • Features associated with disease-specific events (4):[4]
    1. Tumour size
    2. Small-vessel invasion
    3. Sarcomatoid features
    4. Microscopic necrosis
    • pT stage or nodal metastasis tended to show some association, without reaching statistical significance
Commonly seen Birt-Hogg-Dubé syndrome; most cases are sporadic
Collecting duct carcinoma (<1%) Originates from collecting duct

Stains positive with Ulex europaeus lectin

Poor prognosis; most reported cases have been high grade, advanced stage, and unresponsive to conventional therapies

May share features in common with urothelial carcinoma; advanced collecting duct carcinoma may respond to cisplatin or gemcitabine-based chemotherapy

Unknown

Multiple chromosomal losses

Renal medullary carcinoma (rare) Originates from collecting duct

Dismal prognosis; many cases are both locally advanced and metastatic at the time of diagnosis

Associated with sickle cell trait (NOT disease); typically diagnosed in young African-Americans
Unclassified RCC

(1%-3%)

Origin not defined

Poor prognosis, most are poorly differentiated and are associated with a highly aggressive biologic behavior

Unknown
RCC associated with Xp11.2

translocations/TFE3

gene fusions (rare)

Occurs in children and young adults; 40% of pediatric RCC

Prognosis similar to ccRCC

Various mutations involving chromosome Xp11.2

resulting in TFE3 gene fusion

Post-neuroblastoma

RCC (rare)

Occurs exclusively in children with prior neuroblastoma Unknown
Mucinous tubular and spindle cell (rare) Favorable prognosis Unknown

Other histologic features

  • Sarcomatoid differentiation
    • Found in 1-5% of RCCs
    • Not a distinct histologic subtype of RCC, most commonly in association with ccRCC and chromophobe RCC
    • Associated with worse prognosis; multimodal approaches should be considered
  • Cystic degeneration
    • Found in 10-25% of RCCs
    • Associated with better prognosis compared with purely solid RCC
  • Laterality and focality
    • Most sporadic RCCs are unilateral and unifocal
    • Bilateral involvement
      • Occurs in 2-4% of sporadic RCCs
        • More common in patients with familial forms of RCC (e.g. von Hippel-Lindau disease).
      • Can be synchronous or asynchronous
        • If synchronous, likely an independent growth
        • If asynchronous, likely a metastasis
    • Multifocality
      • Occurs in 10-20% of cases
      • More common with papillary histology and familial RCC
      • Microsatellite analysis suggests a clonal origin for most multifocal RCC

Grade

  • Based primarily on nuclear size, shape, and presence of predominant nucleoli
  • Fuhrman Grading system
    • Described in 1982
  • International Society of Urological Pathology (ISUP) Grading system
    • Proposed in 2012, updated in 2016
    • Incorporates aspects of the Fuhrman Grading system but includes more objective criteria for nuclear characteristics.
    • Sarcomatoid and rhabdoid tumors, tumors with giant cells, and tumors with extreme nuclear pleomorphism are included within grade 4 tumors.
    • Chromophobe RCC is no longer graded in the ISUP system.
  • In general, higher grade is associated with larger tumor size and more aggressive tumors.

Questions

  1. What the prognosis of ccRCC relative to chromophobe and papillary RCC? Which papillary RCC subtype is associated with better prognosis relative to the other?
  2. Patients with ESRD or acquired renal cystic disease are more likely to develop which type of RCC?
  3. Which RCC histology stains for Hale colloidal iron?
  4. Which RCC histologies arise from the proximal tubule vs. collecting duct?

Answers

  1. What the prognosis of ccRCC relative to chromophobe and papillary RCC? Which papillary RCC subtype is associated with better prognosis relative to the other?
    • Prognosis of ccRCC is worse than chromophobe and papillary RCC
    • Type II papillary RCC has worse prognosis than type I
  2. Patients with ESRD or acquired renal cystic disease are more likely to develop with type of RCC?
    • Papillary
  3. Which RCC histology stains for Hale colloidal iron?
    • Chromophobe
  4. Which RCC histologies arise from the proximal tubule vs. collecting duct?
    1. Proximal tubule:
      1. Clear cell
      2. Papillary
    2. Collecting duct
      1. Chromophobe
      2. Collecting duct
      3. Medullary

Next Chapter: TNM Staging

References

  • Wein AJ, Kavoussi LR, Partin AW, Peters CA (eds): CAMPBELL-WALSH UROLOGY, ed 11. Philadelphia, Elsevier, 2015, chap 57
  • Campbell, Steven C., et al. "Renal Mass and Localized Renal Cancer: Evaluation, Management, and Follow-Up: AUA Guideline Part I." The Journal of urology (2021): 10-1097.